So I'm leaving my thoughts here as a foster mom of between 5-7 cats/kittens at all times plus my own two cats. I wanted to try Picky Cat because I have tried World's Best Cat Litter before and didn't like it. I tried the regular kind and the lavender scented one. They both flopped in my foster room. I also wanted to try it because I wanted something to attract the young kittens to the litter boxes more instead of random corners. My one personal cat also is stubborn to the point of pooping in the bathtub or random spots around the house.
So I gave it a go and mixed it in little by little as instructed. When the litter goes down fresh it is really pleasant. You get no dust and it smells nice. After a couple of days of heavy use I have noticed the litter grinding down to a fine sand. It can become a little dusty around where the cats go in and out. The smell is what bothers me a lot after its been used. It will take on a scent of barnyard. I feel like I'm sitting in the middle of a petting zoo farm. I am meticulous to keep the boxes cleaned at least twice a day. I did notice most of the cats gravitated towards the box with the Picky Cat in it. (I left the other two without it to test) So the cats like it but the kittens didn't have less accidents.
I used some Picky Cat in my cats personal box. He is the pooper! He used it as usual but it also didn't stop him from pooping in random spots as usual. I did notice that if this litter isn't used in a heavy traffic area then it's a bit better on the consistency and smell over use.
So the cats didn't mind using it and maybe a few preferred it. I would probably use it as a sprinkled additive to help attract them to the box more but that would be the extent of it. It is a little expensive but the coupons help relieve that. I only found the litter at Petco so it kind of is a letdown I couldn't find it at Walmart or Target locally.
Here's a video I made of my thoughts